Simple & Delicious Roasted Tomato Sauce Recipe: Enjoy Now, or Preserve & Freeze!

Tomatoes. Olive oil. Salt. Pepper. No measurements. It really can’t get much more simple than that, can it? Despite the short ingredient list, this roasted tomato sauce is far from falling short in flavor! The process of oven-roasting tomatoes brings out their rich, sweet flavor, introduces a savory punch, and also helps to thicken the sauce. When we are looking to preserve a large amount of homegrown tomatoes from the garden, this is our go-to recipe! We also love to dehydrate them to create sun-dried tomatoes. You can find a tutorial for how to do that here.

Unlike a traditional pizza or pasta sauce, we choose to not add other herbs or spices to our tomato sauce – yet. Instead, this recipe will create a thick, delicious tomato sauce that can be used in a wide variety of ways, not just in Italian dishes! For example, we love to add this sauce to Indian-style recipes, like our madras curry lentils. Or, added to various soups and stews. When desired, it is very easy to doctor up this base sauce with additional seasonings to match the meal you’re making!

Aside from being dang tasty, this tomato sauce is also incredibly easy to make – and preserve! Every summer, we spend an afternoon or two making a large batch of roasted tomato sauce to stock the freezer. Few things are more gratifying than pulling a jar of summery homegrown tomato sauce from the freezer in the middle of winter.

Even if you don’t grow your own tomatoes, I highly suggest making this sauce with fresh local tomatoes while they’re in season to enjoy later. Go hit up the farmer’s market. Your winter recipes will be so much brighter than using commercially-canned tomatoes!  

Ready to get roasting?

INGREDIENTS & SUPPLIES

• Tomatoes – any variety can be used!
• Olive oil, for drizzling (but do NOT use any oil if you intend to hot-bath can this recipe)
• Sea salt
• Black pepper
• Baking or roasting pan
• Large pot
• Blender – we use an immersion blender for this recipe 
• Optional: parchment paper 

INSTRUCTIONS

Step 1: Prepare & Season Tomatoes

Preheat the oven to 425°F

Wash those ‘maters, and get to choppin’! The other beautiful thing about this recipe is that because everything is going to get cooked and blended, size and shape doesn’t matter much here – nor do we need to worry about removing the skins! We also leave the guts, which enhances the caramelization process.

Cut away the firm stem center (if there is one), and then portion your tomatoes into chunks. We typically cut the smaller tomatoes in half, and larger ones into quarters or sixths. You can totally leave cherry tomatoes whole! 

On a baking sheet, lay out all the tomato pieces – skin-side down if possible. Lining the baking sheet with parchment paper makes for a much easier clean-up, since the tomato juices tend to stick and crust to the pan while roasting. It is okay to pack the tomatoes in there, but try to keep them in a single layer. **If you find you have more tomatoes than can fit on your pans for the oven, but want to process and preserve them all, check out optional Step 3! 

Now, drizzle the tomatoes with olive oil, and give them a sprinkle of sea salt and black pepper. Again, omit the olive oil if you wish to can your sauce.

Step 2: Roast the Tomatoes

Here is where the magic happens. 

When exposed to high and dry heat, foods take on a whole new complex flavor profile because of the chemical reactions that take place. Namely, caramelization.

According to the Science of Cooking, caramelization is an oxidative reaction that involves the removal of water (as steam) and the breakdown of the sugar. As the the browning process occurs, natural volatile chemicals are released that produce the characteristic caramel flavor.  Thus, roasting vegetables can transform their earthy, vegetal, sometimes slightly bitter taste into something sweet, nutty, and toasted instead!

Roast the tomatoes in the oven on 425°F for approximately 35 to 45 minutes, until they become soft and lightly browned – or even a tad blackened, like ours! If you’re working with multiple trays of tomatoes, rotate them partway through to promote even roasting. 

Step 3: Stew Other Tomatoes (Optional)

For the batch of sauce we made in this example, we filled two cookie sheets and one large glass roasting pan with tomatoes. The oven was full, but we still had gobs on the counter! Rather than roasting them all in multiple batches (no time for that!) we opted to simply not roast some at all. Instead, we stewed the left over tomatoes – and combined them with the roasted ones when they came out of the oven. The flavor is still phenomenal. If you’re in the same situation, try this option!

While the initial trays of tomatoes are roasting in the oven, process your leftovers. Prepare them in a similar fashion as the others: cut away any tough stem portion, and chop them into a few chunks each. Heat a large pot on the stovetop, and add a splash of olive oil followed by the extra tomatoes. Lightly simmer the tomatoes (uncovered) the entire time the others are in the oven – at least 30 minutes. Stir occasionally. They will become soft, wonderfully fragrant, and the liquid will reduce. 

Step 4: Reduce & Blend the Roasted Tomatoes

Once your tomatoes are finished roasting, you have a couple of options. If you are using a traditional blender and did not stew any additional tomatoes on the stove, you could transfer the roasted tomatoes directly to your blender. I would allow them to cool slightly first to avoid hot splatters! 

However, if you want to reduce the tomatoes even more to create an extra thick sauce (or if you have those other tomatoes already stewing in a pot) transfer the roasted tomatoes into a pot on the stove.  Heat and simmer to further reduce the chunky sauce to a thickness of your liking – but keep in mind it will become even thicker once it is blended! 

Next, blend the tomatoes until the sauce is a smooth, creamy consistency. Using an immersion blender makes this extremely easy, right in the pot! We love this immersion blender, and use it regularly for many recipes – like this creamy roasted carrot and sweet potato soup! Alternatively, blend your roasted tomato sauce in a classic blender in batches as needed. You could choose to leave it chunky and not blend it at all. But keep in mind the skins will be more noticeable and potentially tough if they aren’t blended. 

After blending, assess the thickness. If you want it thicker even still, continue to simmer on medium-low heat to reduce further. Or, if it is all good to go, continue to the next step!

Step 5: Cool, Pack & Store

Now, allow that delicious, hot roasted tomato sauce to cool down a bit. When you package it into your storage containers of choice, the temperature can still be warm – but shouldn’t be hot. To promote rapid cooling, we usually create an “ice bath”, setting the pot surrounded in ice water in a clean sink. Yeah, I used to be a health inspector.

Freezing Roasted Tomato Sauce 

To preserve and freeze this sauce, we typically use pint-sized mason jars. Yes, you can safely freeze food in glass jars! However, make sure you get the ones that are marked as freezer-safe. Those are usually only the wide-mouth pint, half-pint, and quarter-pint size. Glass jars with a “shoulder” are more prone to cracking in the freezer, such as quart jars or curved pints. We freeze in glass whenever possible, though we also have these BPA-free plastic containers for larger quarts of frozen goodies. 

Once the sauce is decently cooled, fill your jars up! This can be a bit messy, so we call on the assistance of a canning jar funnel. Maintain at least one inch of head space to allow for expansion in the freezer.  Store the jars of roasted tomato sauce in the freezer, and use within one year for the best quality and flavor. 

What About Canning?

We prefer the ease and guaranteed safety of freezing tomatoes, but if canning is your thing, be my guest! I won’t get into detailed instructions on exactly how to can tomatoes, but here are some quick safety notes below. For more detailed canning instructions, check out this guide from Colorado State University. Similar to the freezer option, it is suggested to use canned tomatoes within one year. Only proceed with canning if you didn’t use olive oil in this recipe.

To ensure safe acidity in whole, crushed or juiced tomatoes, add bottled lemon juice or citric acid when processing in a boiling water bath. Thoroughly stir in 2 tablespoons of bottled lemon juice or 1/2 teaspoon of citric acid per quart of tomatoes. For pints, use 1 tablespoon bottled lemon juice or 1/4 teaspoon of citric acid.

Colorado State University

Processing Time (minutes) for Canning Tomato Sauce	Pints	Quarts
Boiling Water Bath at Altitudes Of:
0-3,000 ft.	40	45
3,001-6,000 ft	45	50
6,001-8,000 ft	50	55
8,001-10,000 ft	55	60
Pressure Canner*	15	15

Step 6: Enjoy!

Now you get to enjoy the fruits of your labor, and use this roasted tomato sauce however you see fit! As I mentioned, we often simply dump a jar into homemade soups, curries, beans, lentils, or other saucy meals. Basically, anything that calls for canned tomatoes or paste! We also plan to make a sourdough pizza this weekend and use this as the sauce. We won’t modify it at all, since the flavor is wonderful as-is. Our pizza crust recipe already includes herbs in the dough, and we can sprinkle more fresh herbs like thyme and oregano right on top of the sauce before baking! This sauce would also be the bomb drizzled over our parmesan zucchini fritters.

To transform this sauce into a more classic Italian pasta sauce: Start by sautéing some diced onions and garlic in a pan until they’re soft and translucent. Then add the roasted tomato sauce, salt and pepper, plus fresh or dried herbs like basil, thyme, oregano, and rosemary – to taste. In the place of fresh garlic and onion, you could even substitute with garlic powder or onion powder! Simmer to combine flavors. Voilà! Delizioso!

I told you we were going to keep it simple! I hope you love and use this recipe as much as we do. Please feel free to ask questions, and spread the tomato love by sharing this post!

If you enjoyed this article, I think you’re going to like these as well:

• Preserving Tomatoes: How to Make Herb Sun-Dried Tomatoes in a Dehydrator or Oven
• Preserving Garlic: How to Make Homemade Garlic Powder
• The Besto Pesto: Lemon Walnut Basil Pesto Recipe
• Madras Curry Lentils Recipe
• Easy Parmesan Zucchini Fritters Recipe with Healthy Yogurt Dill Sauce
• Creamy Vegan Roasted Carrot and Sweet Potato Soup
• Easy Refrigerator Pickled Peppers Recipe
• Preserving Onions: How to Make Onion Powder